[SCIP] How to get all the 2 solutions with SCIP solver?

Stefan Vigerske stefan at math.hu-berlin.de
Thu Feb 18 17:57:29 CET 2016


Hi,

On 02/18/2016 02:31 PM, Fred Young wrote:
> Hi, all,
> I used the academic version of OPTI toolbox with SCIP solver to solve a
> MINLP problem, all the variables are either binary or integer.
> After the implementation of the code,  I found the matlab command window
> outputs:
> ........
> ........
> SCIP Status        : solving was interrupted [node limit reached]
> Solving Time (sec) : 239.07
> Solving Nodes      : 10000
> Primal Bound       : +8.08620534391534e+000 (2 solutions)
> Dual Bound         : +7.60332402116402e+000
> Gap                : 6.35
>
> -------------------------------------------------------
> Now I have two questions:
> (1)   "......Primal Bound       : +8.08620534391534e+000 (2 solutions)...."
> , it says there are 2 solutions, does this mean that  there are two group
> of variables x_i can bring the same result fval of min  f(x)?

The second solution will have an equal or worse fval, likely to be worse 
one.

>  If so, using
> function [x,fval,exitflag,info] = solve(Opt,x0) I could get only one group
> of solution of x_i,  how can I get another one?

You should ask that the OptiToolbox developers. They would need to make 
this functionality available in their interface.

>  And, when I limited SCIP
> solution to '1' using the following code, it seems do not work,  it still
> output: ......(2 solutions)......, why?
>
> sopts = scipset('scipopts',{'limits/solutions',1});
> opts =
> optiset('solver','scip','display','iter','maxtime',1000,'maxnodes',10000);
> Opt  =
> opti('fun',fun,'nlmix',nlcon,nlrhs,nle,'bounds',lb,ub,'ineq',A,b,'eq',Aeq,beq,'xtype',xtype,'opts',opts)

Maybe you need pass the sopts into opti() somehow.


>   (2) "...... SCIP Status: solving was interrupted [node limit
> reached]......"  Does this mean that It already got the optimization
> solution under current parameters of SCIP solver?  After increasing the
> maxtime and the maxnodes by 'opts =
> optiset('solver','scip','display','iter','maxtime',10000,'maxnodes',100000);
> '  I found that the resulted x_i and fval remain the same as before except
> it cost more time.  Dose this mean that I have already got the optimal
> feasible solution?

It just means that SCIP has not found a better solution when going 
beyond 10000 nodes.
SCIP tries to find a global optimal solution, that is it wants to find a 
feasible solution and prove that it is optimal. The gap of 6.35 that 
SCIP reports at the end in its log tells you that the solution that it 
reports has an objective functional value that is proven by SCIP to be 
at most 6.35% way from the optimal value of the problem. If you don't 
set time and node limits, SCIP would go on until it can close the gap to 0.

> I would thanks a million if someone can tell me how to get the optimal
> feasible solution in my case.

17.

It may be worthwhile to try setting the SCIP option
   constraints/quadratic/replacebinaryprod = 0

Stefan

>
> Best regards,
> Fred Young
>
>
> All the matlab command window outputs:
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> Mixed Integer Nonlinear Program (MINLP) Optimization
>   min  f(x)
>   s.t. Ax <= b
>        Aeqx = beq
>        lb <= x <= ub
>        ceq(x) = deq
>        xi = Integer / Binary
> ------------------------------------------------------
>     Problem Properties:
> # Decision Variables:      1872
> # Constraints:             7216
>    # Linear Inequality:     864
>    # Linear Equality:       152
>    # Bounds:                3744
>    # Binary Variables:      1296
>    # Integer Variables:     576
>    # Nonlinear Equality:    584
> ------------------------------------------------------
>    Solver Parameters:
> Solver:                    SCIP
> Objective Gradient:        Not Required
> Constraint Jacobian:       Not Required
> Jacobian Structure:        Not Required
> ------------------------------------------------------
> presolving:
> (round 1, fast)       432 del vars, 293 del conss, 144 add conss, 144 chg
> bounds, 195 chg sides, 5 chg coeffs, 433 upgd conss, 0 impls, 144 clqs
> (round 2, fast)       433 del vars, 294 del conss, 144 add conss, 146 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 721 upgd conss, 0 impls, 144 clqs
> (round 3, fast)       433 del vars, 294 del conss, 532 add conss, 146 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 721 upgd conss, 0 impls, 144 clqs
> (round 4, fast)       433 del vars, 294 del conss, 532 add conss, 146 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 729 upgd conss, 0 impls, 4918 clqs
> (round 5, exhaustive) 433 del vars, 434 del conss, 532 add conss, 146 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 729 upgd conss, 0 impls, 4926 clqs
> (round 6, exhaustive) 433 del vars, 434 del conss, 532 add conss, 146 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1241 upgd conss, 0 impls, 4926 clqs
> (round 7, fast)       433 del vars, 434 del conss, 568 add conss, 218 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1241 upgd conss, 144 impls, 4926 clqs
> (round 8, exhaustive) 433 del vars, 470 del conss, 568 add conss, 218 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1241 upgd conss, 144 impls, 4926 clqs
> (round 9, exhaustive) 458 del vars, 470 del conss, 568 add conss, 218 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1241 upgd conss, 44359 impls, 51270
> clqs
> (round 10, fast)       458 del vars, 487 del conss, 712 add conss, 218 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1241 upgd conss, 44359 impls, 51270
> clqs
> (round 11, exhaustive) 458 del vars, 495 del conss, 768 add conss, 218 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1241 upgd conss, 44359 impls, 51270
> clqs
> (round 12, exhaustive) 458 del vars, 567 del conss, 768 add conss, 218 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1241 upgd conss, 44359 impls, 51270
> clqs
> (round 13, exhaustive) 458 del vars, 567 del conss, 768 add conss, 218 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1313 upgd conss, 44359 impls, 51270
> clqs
> (round 14, medium)     458 del vars, 639 del conss, 768 add conss, 218 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1313 upgd conss, 44359 impls, 51270
> clqs
>     (0.8s) probing: 1000/1396 (71.6) - 17 fixings, 8 aggregations, 92016
> implications, 0 bound changes
> (round 15, exhaustive) 483 del vars, 639 del conss, 768 add conss, 218 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1313 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50716
> clqs
> (round 16, fast)       483 del vars, 642 del conss, 912 add conss, 235 chg
> bounds, 339 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1313 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50716
> clqs
> (round 17, fast)       483 del vars, 676 del conss, 912 add conss, 235 chg
> bounds, 373 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1313 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50716
> clqs
> (round 18, exhaustive) 483 del vars, 681 del conss, 968 add conss, 235 chg
> bounds, 373 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1313 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50716
> clqs
> (round 19, exhaustive) 483 del vars, 753 del conss, 968 add conss, 235 chg
> bounds, 373 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1313 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50716
> clqs
> (round 20, exhaustive) 483 del vars, 753 del conss, 968 add conss, 235 chg
> bounds, 373 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1385 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50716
> clqs
> (round 21, medium)     483 del vars, 808 del conss, 968 add conss, 235 chg
> bounds, 373 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1385 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50716
> clqs
> (round 22, exhaustive) 508 del vars, 808 del conss, 968 add conss, 235 chg
> bounds, 373 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1385 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50131
> clqs
> (round 23, fast)       508 del vars, 831 del conss, 993 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 373 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1385 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50131
> clqs
> (round 24, fast)       508 del vars, 835 del conss, 993 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1385 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50131
> clqs
> (round 25, exhaustive) 508 del vars, 841 del conss, 993 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1385 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50131
> clqs
> (round 26, exhaustive) 508 del vars, 841 del conss, 993 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50131
> clqs
> (round 27, medium)     508 del vars, 858 del conss, 993 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 50131
> clqs
> (round 28, exhaustive) 533 del vars, 858 del conss, 993 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 49556
> clqs
> (round 29, fast)       533 del vars, 883 del conss, 1018 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 49556
> clqs
> (round 30, exhaustive) 533 del vars, 908 del conss, 1018 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 49556
> clqs
> (round 31, exhaustive) 558 del vars, 908 del conss, 1018 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 48981
> clqs
> (round 32, fast)       558 del vars, 933 del conss, 1043 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 48981
> clqs
> (round 33, exhaustive) 558 del vars, 958 del conss, 1043 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 48981
> clqs
> (round 34, exhaustive) 583 del vars, 958 del conss, 1043 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 48400
> clqs
> (round 35, fast)       583 del vars, 983 del conss, 1068 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 48400
> clqs
> (round 36, exhaustive) 583 del vars, 992 del conss, 1068 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1404 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 48400
> clqs
> (round 37, exhaustive) 583 del vars, 992 del conss, 1068 add conss, 237 chg
> bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1420 upgd conss, 45517 impls, 48400
> clqs
> (round 38, medium)     583 del vars, 1008 del conss, 1068 add conss, 237
> chg bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1420 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 48400 clqs
> (round 39, exhaustive) 608 del vars, 1008 del conss, 1068 add conss, 237
> chg bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1420 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 47700 clqs
> (round 40, fast)       608 del vars, 1011 del conss, 1093 add conss, 262
> chg bounds, 377 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1420 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 47700 clqs
> (round 41, fast)       608 del vars, 1058 del conss, 1093 add conss, 262
> chg bounds, 419 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1420 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 47700 clqs
> (round 42, exhaustive) 608 del vars, 1058 del conss, 1093 add conss, 262
> chg bounds, 419 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 47700 clqs
> (round 43, exhaustive) 633 del vars, 1058 del conss, 1093 add conss, 262
> chg bounds, 419 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 47000 clqs
> (round 44, fast)       633 del vars, 1068 del conss, 1118 add conss, 287
> chg bounds, 419 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 47000 clqs
> (round 45, fast)       633 del vars, 1108 del conss, 1118 add conss, 287
> chg bounds, 444 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 47000 clqs
> (round 46, exhaustive) 658 del vars, 1108 del conss, 1118 add conss, 287
> chg bounds, 444 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 46300 clqs
> (round 47, fast)       658 del vars, 1108 del conss, 1143 add conss, 312
> chg bounds, 444 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 46300 clqs
> (round 48, fast)       658 del vars, 1158 del conss, 1143 add conss, 312
> chg bounds, 469 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 45517 impls,
> 46300 clqs
>     (1.3s) probing cycle finished: starting next cycle
> (round 49, exhaustive) 683 del vars, 1158 del conss, 1143 add conss, 330
> chg bounds, 469 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45714 clqs
> (round 50, fast)       683 del vars, 1194 del conss, 1287 add conss, 333
> chg bounds, 498 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45714 clqs
> (round 51, fast)       683 del vars, 1199 del conss, 1287 add conss, 333
> chg bounds, 503 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45714 clqs
> (round 52, exhaustive) 683 del vars, 1203 del conss, 1301 add conss, 333
> chg bounds, 503 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45714 clqs
> (round 53, exhaustive) 683 del vars, 1268 del conss, 1301 add conss, 333
> chg bounds, 503 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1437 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45714 clqs
> (round 54, exhaustive) 683 del vars, 1268 del conss, 1301 add conss, 333
> chg bounds, 503 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1509 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45714 clqs
> (round 55, medium)     683 del vars, 1326 del conss, 1301 add conss, 333
> chg bounds, 503 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1509 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45714 clqs
> (round 56, exhaustive) 708 del vars, 1326 del conss, 1301 add conss, 333
> chg bounds, 503 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1509 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45245 clqs
> (round 57, fast)       708 del vars, 1335 del conss, 1333 add conss, 358
> chg bounds, 503 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1509 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45245 clqs
> (round 58, fast)       708 del vars, 1351 del conss, 1333 add conss, 358
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1509 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45245 clqs
> (round 59, exhaustive) 708 del vars, 1353 del conss, 1333 add conss, 358
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1509 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45245 clqs
> (round 60, exhaustive) 708 del vars, 1353 del conss, 1333 add conss, 358
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1530 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45245 clqs
> (round 61, medium)     708 del vars, 1358 del conss, 1333 add conss, 358
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1530 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 45245 clqs
> (round 62, exhaustive) 733 del vars, 1358 del conss, 1333 add conss, 358
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1530 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 44470 clqs
> (round 63, fast)       733 del vars, 1362 del conss, 1360 add conss, 383
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1530 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 44470 clqs
> (round 64, fast)       733 del vars, 1383 del conss, 1360 add conss, 383
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1530 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 44470 clqs
> (round 65, exhaustive) 733 del vars, 1384 del conss, 1360 add conss, 383
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1531 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 44470 clqs
> (round 66, exhaustive) 758 del vars, 1385 del conss, 1360 add conss, 383
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1531 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43695 clqs
> (round 67, fast)       758 del vars, 1385 del conss, 1387 add conss, 408
> chg bounds, 519 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1531 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43695 clqs
> (round 68, fast)       758 del vars, 1410 del conss, 1387 add conss, 408
> chg bounds, 530 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1531 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43695 clqs
> (round 69, exhaustive) 758 del vars, 1411 del conss, 1387 add conss, 408
> chg bounds, 530 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1543 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43695 clqs
> (round 70, exhaustive) 783 del vars, 1412 del conss, 1387 add conss, 408
> chg bounds, 530 chg sides, 149 chg coeffs, 1543 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43403 clqs
> (round 71, fast)       783 del vars, 1413 del conss, 1416 add conss, 450
> chg bounds, 530 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1543 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43403 clqs
> (round 72, fast)       783 del vars, 1438 del conss, 1416 add conss, 450
> chg bounds, 555 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1543 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43403 clqs
> (round 73, exhaustive) 783 del vars, 1440 del conss, 1416 add conss, 450
> chg bounds, 577 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1543 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43403 clqs
> (round 74, exhaustive) 783 del vars, 1440 del conss, 1416 add conss, 450
> chg bounds, 577 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1570 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43403 clqs
> (round 75, medium)     783 del vars, 1442 del conss, 1416 add conss, 450
> chg bounds, 577 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1570 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 43403 clqs
> (round 76, exhaustive) 808 del vars, 1442 del conss, 1416 add conss, 450
> chg bounds, 577 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1570 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42865 clqs
> (round 77, fast)       808 del vars, 1455 del conss, 1445 add conss, 494
> chg bounds, 577 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1570 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42865 clqs
> (round 78, fast)       808 del vars, 1480 del conss, 1445 add conss, 494
> chg bounds, 596 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1570 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42865 clqs
> (round 79, exhaustive) 808 del vars, 1482 del conss, 1445 add conss, 494
> chg bounds, 621 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1570 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42865 clqs
> (round 80, exhaustive) 808 del vars, 1482 del conss, 1445 add conss, 494
> chg bounds, 621 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1578 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42865 clqs
> (round 81, medium)     808 del vars, 1484 del conss, 1445 add conss, 494
> chg bounds, 621 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1578 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42865 clqs
> (round 82, exhaustive) 833 del vars, 1484 del conss, 1445 add conss, 494
> chg bounds, 621 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1578 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42215 clqs
> (round 83, fast)       833 del vars, 1484 del conss, 1472 add conss, 544
> chg bounds, 621 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1578 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42215 clqs
> (round 84, fast)       833 del vars, 1509 del conss, 1472 add conss, 544
> chg bounds, 621 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1578 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42215 clqs
> (round 85, exhaustive) 833 del vars, 1510 del conss, 1472 add conss, 544
> chg bounds, 646 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1578 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 42215 clqs
> (round 86, exhaustive) 858 del vars, 1510 del conss, 1472 add conss, 544
> chg bounds, 646 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1579 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 41565 clqs
> (round 87, fast)       858 del vars, 1515 del conss, 1499 add conss, 582
> chg bounds, 646 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1579 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 41565 clqs
> (round 88, fast)       858 del vars, 1535 del conss, 1499 add conss, 582
> chg bounds, 655 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1579 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 41565 clqs
> (round 89, exhaustive) 858 del vars, 1537 del conss, 1499 add conss, 582
> chg bounds, 680 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1579 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 41565 clqs
> (round 90, exhaustive) 858 del vars, 1537 del conss, 1499 add conss, 582
> chg bounds, 680 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1589 upgd conss, 46779 impls,
> 41565 clqs
>     (2.1s) probing: 1000/1151 (86.9) - 413 fixings, 18 aggregations, 152895
> implications, 18 bound changes
>     (2.1s) probing: 1076/1151 (93.5) - 413 fixings, 18 aggregations, 153854
> implications, 20 bound changes
>     (2.1s) probing aborted: 50/50 successive totally useless probings
> (round 91, exhaustive) 864 del vars, 1538 del conss, 1499 add conss, 584
> chg bounds, 680 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1589 upgd conss, 104682 impls,
> 41203 clqs
> (round 92, fast)       865 del vars, 1540 del conss, 1642 add conss, 590
> chg bounds, 681 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1589 upgd conss, 104682 impls,
> 41203 clqs
> (round 93, fast)       865 del vars, 1543 del conss, 1642 add conss, 590
> chg bounds, 683 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1589 upgd conss, 104682 impls,
> 41203 clqs
> (round 94, fast)       865 del vars, 1543 del conss, 1645 add conss, 590
> chg bounds, 683 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1590 upgd conss, 104682 impls,
> 41203 clqs
> (round 95, medium)     866 del vars, 1545 del conss, 1645 add conss, 590
> chg bounds, 683 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1590 upgd conss, 104684 impls,
> 41203 clqs
> (round 96, exhaustive) 866 del vars, 1618 del conss, 1645 add conss, 590
> chg bounds, 740 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1590 upgd conss, 104684 impls,
> 41203 clqs
> (round 97, exhaustive) 867 del vars, 1619 del conss, 1645 add conss, 590
> chg bounds, 740 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1661 upgd conss, 104684 impls,
> 41203 clqs
> (round 98, medium)     867 del vars, 1687 del conss, 1645 add conss, 590
> chg bounds, 740 chg sides, 152 chg coeffs, 1661 upgd conss, 104684 impls,
> 41203 clqs
>     (2.2s) probing: 1081/1151 (93.9) - 413 fixings, 18 aggregations, 153854
> implications, 20 bound changes
>     (2.2s) probing aborted: 50/50 successive totally useless probings
> presolving (99 rounds: 99 fast, 61 medium, 51 exhaustive):
>   868 deleted vars, 1688 deleted constraints, 1645 added constraints, 590
> tightened bounds, 0 added holes, 740 changed sides, 152 changed coefficients
>   104684 implications, 41203 cliques
> presolved problem has 1394 variables (964 bin, 430 int, 0 impl, 0 cont) and
> 1558 constraints
>      232 constraints of type <varbound>
>      159 constraints of type <setppc>
>      372 constraints of type <and>
>      365 constraints of type <linear>
>      287 constraints of type <bounddisjunction>
>      143 constraints of type <quadratic>
> Presolving Time: 2.20
>
>   time | node  | left  |LP iter|LP it/n| mem |mdpt |frac |vars |cons |cols
> |rows |cuts |confs|strbr|  dualbound   | primalbound  |  gap
>    2.4s|     1 |     0 |  1506 |     - |  27M|   0 |  70 |1394 |1661 |1394
> |1573 |   0 |  30 |   0 |7.603324e+000 |      --      |    Inf
> U 4.8s|     1 |     0 |  1876 |     - |  28M|   0 |  70 |1394 |1661 |1394
> |1573 |   0 |  30 |   0 |7.603324e+000 |9.691415e+000 |  27.46
>    5.0s|     1 |     0 |  3072 |     - |  29M|   0 |  76 |1394 |1661 |1394
> |1727 | 154 |  30 |   0 |7.603324e+000 |9.691415e+000 |  27.46
>    5.0s|     1 |     0 |  3072 |     - |  28M|   0 |  76 |1394 |1661 |1394
> |1661 | 154 |  30 |   0 |7.603324e+000 |9.691415e+000 |  27.46
>    5.1s|     1 |     0 |  4517 |     - |  28M|   0 | 121 |1394 |1661 |1394
> |1738 | 231 |  30 |   0 |7.603324e+000 |9.691415e+000 |  27.46
>    5.3s|     1 |     0 |  6017 |     - |  29M|   0 |   - |1394 |1661 |1394
> |1808 | 301 |  30 |   0 |7.603324e+000 |9.691415e+000 |  27.46
> (node 1) LP solver hit iteration limit in LP 14 -- using pseudo solution
> instead
>    5.3s|     1 |     2 |  6017 |     - |  29M|   0 |   - |1394 |1661 |1394
> |1808 | 301 |  30 |   0 |7.603324e+000 |9.691415e+000 |  27.46
>   10.6s|   100 |   101 |160155 |1556.9 |  28M|  35 |   - |1394 |1661 |1394
> |2084 | 597 |  30 |   0 |7.603324e+000 |9.691415e+000 |  27.46
>   32.3s|   200 |   140 |292842 |1441.3 |  29M|  56 | 104 |1394 |1722 |1394
> |2543 |2772 |  91 | 646 |7.603324e+000 |9.691415e+000 |  27.46
> N32.5s|   201 |   134 |292854 |1434.2 |  29M|  56 | 121 |1394 |1722 |1394
> |2456 |2776 |  91 | 646 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   38.0s|   300 |   204 |364525 |1199.0 |  30M|  56 |  79 |1394 |2041 |1394
> |2449 |3986 | 410 | 692 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   42.1s|   400 |   272 |420219 |1038.1 |  31M|  56 |   - |1394 |2134 |1394
> |2554 |6952 | 503 | 728 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   49.2s|   500 |   333 |502763 | 995.5 |  33M|  56 |   - |1394 |2261 |1394
> |2451 |9029 | 630 | 923 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
>   53.9s|   600 |   398 |550036 | 908.2 |  35M|  56 |   - |1394 |2342 |1394
> |2536 |9305 | 711 |1050 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
> Exception of type: TOO_FEW_DOF in file
> "..\src\Interfaces\IpIpoptApplication.cpp" at line 887:
>   Exception message: status != TOO_FEW_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM evaluated false:
> Too few degrees of freedom (rethrown)!
>   57.5s|   700 |   479 |573286 | 811.5 |  36M|  56 |   0 |1394 |2363 |1394
> |2531 |9311 | 732 |1051 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   time | node  | left  |LP iter|LP it/n| mem |mdpt |frac |vars |cons |cols
> |rows |cuts |confs|strbr|  dualbound   | primalbound  |  gap
>   60.9s|   800 |   551 |608641 | 754.2 |  36M|  56 |   - |1394 |2396 |1394
> |2479 |9414 | 765 |1085 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   63.8s|   900 |   636 |634218 | 698.8 |  36M|  56 |   0 |1394 |2411 |1394
> |2497 |9458 | 780 |1095 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   66.1s|  1000 |   726 |668357 | 663.0 |  37M|  58 |   0 |1394 |2428 |1394
> |2488 |9530 | 797 |1112 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   67.6s|  1100 |   808 |691944 | 624.1 |  37M|  59 |  78 |1394 |2456 |1394
> |2505 |9604 | 825 |1113 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   69.2s|  1200 |   874 |720825 | 596.2 |  37M|  59 |   0 |1394 |2503 |1394
> |2484 |9620 | 872 |1114 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   70.7s|  1300 |   933 |742613 | 567.0 |  38M|  62 |   0 |1394 |2585 |1394
> |2472 |9699 | 954 |1143 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   72.0s|  1400 |  1016 |763149 | 541.2 |  38M|  62 |   - |1394 |2619 |   0
> |   0 |9731 | 988 |1158 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   73.3s|  1500 |  1106 |777721 | 514.8 |  38M|  65 |   0 |1394 |2679 |1394
> |2472 |9774 |1049 |1202 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   74.8s|  1600 |  1198 |799643 | 496.3 |  39M|  65 |   - |1394 |2718 |1394
> |2486 |9819 |1088 |1231 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   79.2s|  1700 |  1278 |834099 | 487.4 |  39M|  67 |  30 |1394 |2743 |1394
> |2481 |  10k|1115 |1436 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   81.5s|  1800 |  1362 |871231 | 480.9 |  40M|  67 |   0 |1394 |2776 |1394
> |2492 |  10k|1149 |1478 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   83.4s|  1900 |  1455 |896126 | 468.7 |  40M|  67 |   0 |1394 |2795 |1394
> |2475 |  11k|1168 |1506 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   86.1s|  2000 |  1545 |938346 | 466.4 |  40M|  68 |   0 |1394 |2828 |1394
> |2486 |  11k|1201 |1573 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   87.6s|  2100 |  1635 |965002 | 456.9 |  41M|  72 |   0 |1394 |2833 |1394
> |2488 |  12k|1207 |1577 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   89.2s|  2200 |  1715 |986873 | 446.0 |  41M|  78 |   0 |1394 |2894 |1394
> |2487 |  12k|1269 |1628 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   time | node  | left  |LP iter|LP it/n| mem |mdpt |frac |vars |cons |cols
> |rows |cuts |confs|strbr|  dualbound   | primalbound  |  gap
>   94.4s|  2300 |  1797 |  1057k| 457.5 |  41M|  78 |   - |1394 |2870 |1394
> |2807 |  13k|1280 |1716 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   98.2s|  2400 |  1884 |  1123k| 465.7 |  42M|  78 |   0 |1394 |2865 |1394
> |2487 |  15k|1287 |1783 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   99.5s|  2500 |  1984 |  1142k| 454.9 |  42M|  78 |   0 |1394 |2865 |1394
> |2486 |  15k|1287 |1802 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    100s|  2600 |  2084 |  1147k| 439.2 |  43M|  78 |   0 |1394 |2864 |1394
> |2479 |  15k|1287 |1802 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    102s|  2700 |  2172 |  1172k| 432.2 |  43M|  78 |   0 |1394 |2883 |1394
> |2481 |  16k|1306 |1845 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    103s|  2800 |  2260 |  1192k| 423.8 |  43M|  99 |   1 |1394 |2890 |1394
> |2480 |  16k|1318 |1866 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    105s|  2900 |  2343 |  1223k| 419.9 |  44M| 106 |  14 |1394 |2905 |1394
> |2711 |  17k|1335 |1917 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    107s|  3000 |  2420 |  1242k| 412.3 |  44M| 106 |   2 |1394 |2966 |1394
> |2673 |  18k|1403 |2087 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    108s|  3100 |  2520 |  1251k| 402.0 |  45M| 106 |   1 |1394 |3008 |1394
> |2505 |  18k|1449 |2092 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    109s|  3200 |  2618 |  1253k| 390.0 |  45M| 106 |   0 |1394 |3017 |1394
> |2504 |  18k|1458 |2093 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    110s|  3300 |  2710 |  1268k| 382.8 |  45M| 106 |   - |1394 |3015 |   0
> |   0 |  18k|1458 |2101 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    112s|  3400 |  2804 |  1279k| 374.6 |  46M| 106 |   0 |1394 |3019 |1394
> |2473 |  18k|1467 |2106 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    113s|  3500 |  2890 |  1301k| 370.2 |  46M| 106 |   1 |1394 |3039 |1394
> |2473 |  19k|1487 |2106 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    115s|  3600 |  2981 |  1312k| 363.1 |  46M| 106 |  46 |1394 |3038 |1394
> |2627 |  19k|1506 |2135 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    117s|  3700 |  3058 |  1347k| 362.6 |  47M| 106 |   6 |1394 |3037 |1394
> |2487 |  20k|1535 |2157 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   time | node  | left  |LP iter|LP it/n| mem |mdpt |frac |vars |cons |cols
> |rows |cuts |confs|strbr|  dualbound   | primalbound  |  gap
>    118s|  3800 |  3150 |  1355k| 355.2 |  47M| 107 |  76 |1394 |3032 |1394
> |2540 |  20k|1540 |2175 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    119s|  3900 |  3224 |  1376k| 351.4 |  47M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3018 |1394
> |2488 |  21k|1559 |2211 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    121s|  4000 |  3314 |  1390k| 346.3 |  48M| 110 |   - |1394 |3008 |1394
> |2677 |  21k|1572 |2263 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    124s|  4100 |  3386 |  1447k| 351.8 |  48M| 110 |  54 |1394 |3002 |1394
> |2646 |  23k|1590 |2283 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    126s|  4200 |  3470 |  1484k| 352.1 |  48M| 110 |   8 |1394 |2989 |1394
> |2501 |  24k|1591 |2298 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    128s|  4300 |  3560 |  1510k| 350.1 |  49M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3003 |1394
> |2524 |  25k|1611 |2311 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    129s|  4400 |  3642 |  1531k| 346.7 |  49M| 110 |  24 |1394 |3006 |1394
> |2609 |  25k|1631 |2317 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    130s|  4500 |  3727 |  1544k| 341.9 |  49M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3010 |1394
> |2535 |  26k|1647 |2339 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    131s|  4600 |  3819 |  1548k| 335.5 |  50M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3011 |1394
> |2537 |  26k|1650 |2345 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    132s|  4700 |  3917 |  1553k| 329.3 |  50M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3009 |1394
> |2537 |  26k|1650 |2357 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    133s|  4800 |  4011 |  1557k| 323.3 |  50M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3012 |1394
> |2537 |  26k|1654 |2357 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    135s|  4900 |  4084 |  1589k| 323.3 |  51M| 110 |  21 |1394 |3020 |1394
> |2542 |  27k|1671 |2367 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    137s|  5000 |  4138 |  1618k| 322.5 |  51M| 110 |  11 |1394 |3026 |1394
> |2543 |  28k|1707 |2402 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    138s|  5100 |  4192 |  1635k| 319.5 |  52M| 110 |  47 |1394 |3055 |1394
> |2571 |  29k|1741 |2415 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    140s|  5200 |  4260 |  1659k| 318.1 |  52M| 110 |  11 |1394 |3066 |1394
> |2642 |  30k|1771 |2462 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   time | node  | left  |LP iter|LP it/n| mem |mdpt |frac |vars |cons |cols
> |rows |cuts |confs|strbr|  dualbound   | primalbound  |  gap
>    142s|  5300 |  4321 |  1703k| 320.4 |  53M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3055 |1394
> |2532 |  30k|1775 |2469 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    144s|  5400 |  4394 |  1733k| 319.9 |  53M| 110 |  11 |1394 |3085 |1394
> |2533 |  31k|1816 |2477 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    145s|  5500 |  4449 |  1770k| 320.8 |  54M| 110 |   - |1394 |3079 |1394
> |2543 |  32k|1831 |2486 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    146s|  5600 |  4529 |  1783k| 317.4 |  54M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3096 |1394
> |2537 |  32k|1858 |2508 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    147s|  5700 |  4623 |  1790k| 313.2 |  54M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3084 |1394
> |2538 |  32k|1858 |2516 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    149s|  5800 |  4717 |  1804k| 310.2 |  55M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3072 |1394
> |2537 |  32k|1863 |2531 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    151s|  5900 |  4805 |  1828k| 308.9 |  55M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3062 |1394
> |2538 |  33k|1863 |2537 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    152s|  6000 |  4896 |  1834k| 304.8 |  56M| 110 |   0 |1394 |3067 |1394
> |2487 |  33k|1872 |2542 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    153s|  6100 |  4984 |  1846k| 301.7 |  56M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3062 |1394
> |2537 |  33k|1873 |2551 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    155s|  6200 |  5066 |  1861k| 299.2 |  56M| 110 |   1 |1394 |3059 |1394
> |2485 |  33k|1879 |2551 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    157s|  6300 |  5156 |  1866k| 295.3 |  57M| 110 |   1 |1394 |3057 |1394
> |2537 |  33k|1879 |2551 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    159s|  6400 |  5236 |  1874k| 291.9 |  57M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3053 |1394
> |2537 |  33k|1879 |2551 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    162s|  6500 |  5316 |  1889k| 289.8 |  58M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3049 |1394
> |2537 |  33k|1883 |2551 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    165s|  6600 |  5386 |  1912k| 288.9 |  58M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3044 |1394
> |2537 |  33k|1885 |2551 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    167s|  6700 |  5468 |  1934k| 287.9 |  59M| 110 |   - |1394 |3039 |   0
> |   0 |  34k|1891 |2556 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   time | node  | left  |LP iter|LP it/n| mem |mdpt |frac |vars |cons |cols
> |rows |cuts |confs|strbr|  dualbound   | primalbound  |  gap
>    171s|  6800 |  5550 |  1957k| 287.0 |  59M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3030 |1394
> |2486 |  34k|1898 |2561 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    173s|  6900 |  5630 |  1964k| 283.9 |  60M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3024 |1394
> |2473 |  34k|1898 |2561 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    175s|  7000 |  5712 |  1975k| 281.4 |  60M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3020 |1394
> |2539 |  34k|1898 |2561 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    178s|  7100 |  5784 |  2002k| 281.3 |  61M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3030 |1394
> |2487 |  34k|1913 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    180s|  7200 |  5856 |  2025k| 280.5 |  61M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3021 |1394
> |2487 |  34k|1918 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    183s|  7300 |  5942 |  2052k| 280.4 |  62M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3011 |1394
> |2539 |  34k|1919 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    185s|  7400 |  6028 |  2071k| 279.2 |  62M| 110 |   2 |1394 |3006 |1394
> |2487 |  34k|1921 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    187s|  7500 |  6110 |  2080k| 276.7 |  62M| 110 |   1 |1394 |2990 |1394
> |2486 |  34k|1923 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    188s|  7600 |  6190 |  2094k| 274.8 |  63M| 110 |   1 |1394 |2979 |1394
> |2487 |  34k|1924 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    191s|  7700 |  6272 |  2125k| 275.2 |  63M| 110 |   2 |1394 |2969 |1394
> |2473 |  34k|1924 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    194s|  7800 |  6358 |  2147k| 274.6 |  64M| 110 |   1 |1394 |2962 |1394
> |2486 |  34k|1927 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    196s|  7900 |  6444 |  2169k| 273.9 |  64M| 110 |   2 |1394 |2956 |1394
> |2539 |  34k|1928 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    198s|  8000 |  6528 |  2192k| 273.3 |  65M| 110 |   2 |1394 |2948 |1394
> |2473 |  34k|1930 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    199s|  8100 |  6611 |  2196k| 270.4 |  65M| 110 |   - |1394 |2937 |   0
> |   0 |  34k|1931 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    202s|  8200 |  6691 |  2208k| 268.6 |  66M| 110 |   2 |1394 |2931 |1394
> |2473 |  34k|1931 |2563 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   time | node  | left  |LP iter|LP it/n| mem |mdpt |frac |vars |cons |cols
> |rows |cuts |confs|strbr|  dualbound   | primalbound  |  gap
>    205s|  8300 |  6773 |  2217k| 266.4 |  66M| 110 |   2 |1394 |2926 |1394
> |2487 |  34k|1931 |2566 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    206s|  8400 |  6860 |  2236k| 265.6 |  67M| 111 |   2 |1394 |2927 |1394
> |2488 |  34k|1933 |2568 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    209s|  8500 |  6950 |  2257k| 265.0 |  67M| 116 |   - |1394 |2924 |1394
> |1840 |  34k|1934 |2568 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    211s|  8600 |  7022 |  2279k| 264.4 |  67M| 118 |  24 |1394 |2976 |1394
> |2655 |  35k|2006 |2633 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    213s|  8700 |  7098 |  2300k| 263.8 |  68M| 118 |   0 |1394 |2989 |1394
> |2535 |  36k|2029 |2674 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    214s|  8800 |  7174 |  2342k| 265.5 |  68M| 118 |   2 |1394 |2981 |1394
> |2505 |  36k|2040 |2679 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    216s|  8900 |  7254 |  2345k| 262.9 |  69M| 118 |   1 |1394 |2987 |1394
> |2505 |  36k|2049 |2680 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    219s|  9000 |  7330 |  2352k| 260.7 |  70M| 118 |   1 |1394 |2986 |1394
> |2505 |  36k|2054 |2683 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    221s|  9100 |  7408 |  2372k| 260.1 |  70M| 118 |   - |1394 |2968 |1394
> |1891 |  36k|2054 |2686 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    223s|  9200 |  7486 |  2393k| 259.6 |  71M| 118 |   2 |1394 |2965 |1394
> |2505 |  36k|2058 |2690 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    226s|  9300 |  7565 |  2418k| 259.4 |  71M| 118 |   2 |1394 |2959 |1394
> |2505 |  36k|2059 |2693 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    227s|  9400 |  7643 |  2438k| 258.8 |  72M| 118 |   2 |1394 |2946 |1394
> |2505 |  36k|2061 |2696 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    231s|  9500 |  7723 |  2462k| 258.6 |  72M| 118 |   - |1394 |2940 |1394
> |1840 |  36k|2065 |2699 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    233s|  9600 |  7801 |  2466k| 256.4 |  73M| 118 |   - |1394 |2930 |   0
> |   0 |  36k|2067 |2703 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    234s|  9700 |  7879 |  2495k| 256.7 |  73M| 118 |   2 |1394 |2905 |1394
> |2505 |  37k|2070 |2706 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>   time | node  | left  |LP iter|LP it/n| mem |mdpt |frac |vars |cons |cols
> |rows |cuts |confs|strbr|  dualbound   | primalbound  |  gap
>    236s|  9800 |  7975 |  2522k| 256.8 |  74M| 118 |   2 |1394 |2885 |1394
> |2673 |  37k|2077 |2716 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    238s|  9900 |  8059 |  2524k| 254.4 |  74M| 118 |   2 |1394 |2876 |1394
> |2673 |  37k|2079 |2716 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>    239s| 10000 |  8136 |  2527k| 252.2 |  75M| 118 |   2 |1394 |2875 |1394
> |2673 |  37k|2080 |2716 |7.603324e+000 |8.086205e+000 |   6.35
>
> SCIP Status        : solving was interrupted [node limit reached]
> Solving Time (sec) : 239.07
> Solving Nodes      : 10000
> Primal Bound       : +8.08620534391534e+000 (2 solutions)
> Dual Bound         : +7.60332402116402e+000
> Gap                : 6.35
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Scip mailing list
> Scip at zib.de
> http://listserv.zib.de/mailman/listinfo/scip
>


-- 
http://www.gams.com/~stefan




More information about the Scip mailing list